Abstract
Ports are recognized as crucial nodes in global transport and logistics chains. Port
congestion, that occurs when port demand exceeds the capacity it offers, is one
important phenomenon that prevents ports from fitting into their logistics chains. In
addition to the time loss and high cost imposed on shipping companies, congestion is
also problematic for other port actors.
Over the years, decision-makers believed that spending more on port infra- and
super-structure is the prescription for battling port congestion and the recipe for
improving economic growth. While useful, port capital infra- and super-structure
investments and annual maintenance costs are substantial and may not reap their
intended benefits. As such, the determination of the extent of integration of
ports/terminals among themselves (i.e. horizontal integration) and within the global
supply chains (i.e. vertical integration) have become of great importance.
This Collaborative Research Project (CRP) suggests a paradigm shift from the
traditional supply-driven port investments to a more holistic port planning approach
called “Port Demand Management (PDM)â€. PDM is the application of strategies and
policies to alleviate port congestion by influencing customers’ port/container terminal
choice behaviour (demand) without altering the capacity of the system (supply).
To realize PDM, this research adopts the following twofold approach: First,
understand what factors affect customers’ port/terminal choice behaviour. Second,
provide customers with incentives (disincentives) to attract (repel) them to (from) a
certain port/terminal.
The expected result of this project is a strategic plan for the Egyptian maritime
transport sector utilizing the concepts of horizontal and vertical integration under the
envisioned context of PDM. Special attention will be given to the national container
companies operating under the supervision of the Holding Company for Maritime and
Land Transport (HCMLT), affiliated to the Egyptian government. The findings will
then be scaled to tackle the congestion problem at the port-level.
In general, the benefits of the proposed PDM cannot be overstated as it is expected
to help reduce port/container terminal congestion (without the need to pump huge
infra- and super-structure investments) by directing the state of the system from a
user equilibrium, that captures port/terminal customers’ selfish choice behaviour,
towards a more efficient system optimum.
This project is right up the research alley of MRCC Team given their expertise that
spans across transportation engineering and planning, ports and terminal operation,
shipping lines work, IT applications in the maritime sector, analytical research in the
maritime sector, strategic analysis, quantitative and qualitative research methods,
feasibility studies, corporate social responsibility, and performance evaluation
Project Name
Towards an Integrated Egyptian Maritime Transport Sector: Horizontal and Vertical Integration of Egyptian Commercial Ports
Ref No/ Funded Entity
2046
Project Duration
12month
Project Start Date
2021-10-01
Project End Date
2022-09-30
Total Budget
EGP
Budget of the academy in this project
EGP
Project Website
Go to Website
Objectives
- Egypt is located in the North East of Africa. It is bordered by the Mediterranean Sea
to the North and the Red Sea to the East. Egypt has 15 commercial ports; of which,
six overlook the Mediterranean and nine overlook the Red Sea. Egypt also has the
most significant navigation channel in the world (The Suez Canal) that facilitates the
transit of global trade. The Mediterranean region is characterized by high levels of
competition between its container terminals to obtain a greater share of seaborne
trade volume in the region. Despite the blend that Egyptian ports enjoy, none of the
Egyptian ports/container terminals is among the Top 50 World Container Ports since
2011. In recent years, other competing ports in the Mediterranean region were
among that list, like Port of Piraeus (Greece) and Port of Marsaxlokk (Malta).
The Holding Company for Maritime and Land Transport (HCMLT), affiliated to the
government has three container and cargo handling companies operating through
four container terminals in the following Egyptian ports overlooking the
Mediterranean: Alexandria, El-Dekheila, Damietta, and West Port Said Ports. The
three companies (and the ports they operate at) face many challenges that affect
their performance and financial results.
The goal of this project is to study the reasons for the low performance of the three
national companies and how they could maintain advanced positions among their
competitors in the Mediterranean, and among the Top 50 World Container Ports.
To attain this goal, two wider objectives will be achieved. First, assess the
performance of the three Egyptian container and cargo handling companies and
benchmark them among their rivals in the Eastern Mediterranean region. Second,
identify practically-sound Port Demand Management (PDM) measures and
transportation/port planning policies to support the three Egyptian companies,
individually and combined under HCMLT, to maximize their market shares and
potential as main foreign trade and transhipment players in the region in light of the
rapid developments and severe competition in the maritime transport sector. As
opposed to the traditional supply-driven approach to port planning, PDM aims at the
first place at alleviating port congestion by influencing customers’ (e.g. shipping lines,
shipping alliances, consignees, and/or cargo owners) port/container terminal choice
behaviour (i.e. demand) without investing in additional system capacity (i.e. supply).
The specific objectives of this project are as follows:
1) Conduct a literature review on the concepts of horizontal and vertical integration,
their various types and forms, the main factors and conditions affecting port
integration, and successful applications of these concepts worldwide.
2) Analyze the performance of Alexandria, Port Said, and Damietta Container and
Cargo Handling Companies over a reasonable timeframe.
3) Conduct capacity calculations for the container terminals of the three companies
including their infrastructure (berths, yards, etc.), superstructure (cranes, reach
stackers, etc.), and analyze points of strengths and weaknesses of the
companies ability to utilize their capacity.
4) Analyze the network of shipping lines calling Egyptian ports and the development
of the handling volumes (shares) of these lines with the three Egyptian
companies over the timeframe of the study.
5) Investigate the effect of planned container terminals (i.e. new projects) in
Egyptian ports and the developments in competing container terminals/ports in
the Eastern Mediterranean on the market shares of the three Egyptian container
and cargo handling companies.
6) Identify alternative Port Demand Management (PDM) policies to support the
three Egyptian companies, individually and combined, to maximize their market
shares and potential in the region and solve congestion problems without the
cost of new infrastructure investments.
The challenge facing this project is the balance between the cost of
horizontal/vertical integration (e.g. advantages granted to shipping lines, cost of
inland transportation of goods, etc.) and the desired benefits from such integration
(e.g. retain existing shipping lines and attract new ones to Egyptian ports, use idle
resources, increase revenues, etc.).
Upon completion, this project will offer a strategic plan for the Egyptian maritime
transport sector utilizing the concepts of horizontal and vertical integration under the
envisioned context of Port Demand Management (PDM). Although special attention
will be given to the national container and cargo handling companies, the practical
applications (i.e. policies and strategies) of this research will be scaled to tackle the
congestion problem at the port-level.
Potential success of this project and of Port Demand Management (PDM) as a
concept stems from the fact that demand management; in general, has proven to be
an effective way to reduce urban congestion worldwide [12-15].
Project Coordinator
Dr. Ahmed Osman Idris (PI)
Dean, MRCC
Mobile: 010- 99384898
E-mail: ahmed.idris@aast.edu
This Project is Funded by
AASTMT